Deir Yassin

For a tiny village on the outskirts of Jerusalem, Deir Yassin has certainly made headlines. The events that took place in Deir Yassin in April 1948 are the subject of controversy, both for Israelis and Palestinians. The question is not only what actually happened there, but what impact the events had on Israeli and Palestinian society. This video and the prompts below will help students unpack the mystery surrounding Deir Yassin and encounter the depth and challenges inherent in Israel’s story.

Also available in podcast format

Review
Discussion
Activities
Reflection
Further Learning

Deir Yassin is the name of:
- An Arab village
- An Arab leader
- A city in Jordan
- A Jewish town
Jews often call the 1948 War the _________, while Palestinians often call it the _________.
- Nakba, War of Independence
- War of Independence, Nakba
- Deir Yassin, Six-Day War
- Six-Day War, Deir Yassin
Members of which Jewish paramilitaries carried out the attack on Deir Yassin?
- Haganah and Lechi
- Lechi and Irgun
- Irgun and Haganah
- Irgun and Tzahal
Why is the event of Deir Yassin so closely linked with the Nakba?
What is the controversy surrounding a warning message in Deir Yassin?

Is it possible for two people to have very different accounts of what happened? The Yanny or Laurel dispute helps us understand that it is perhaps quite possible to experience the very same thing differently. How can the Yanny or Laurel dispute help us understand why many Palestinians and Israelis see the history of Deir Yassin differently (or maybe you think it does not at all)?
Some historians claim, and eyewitnesses testify, that the Jewish troops issued a warning to all civilians as they entered the village of Deir Yassin. Others claim that there was no such warning, or that it was only partially heard. Does this warning change the events at hand? Would knowing that there was definitely a warning vindicate the troops or no? Explain.
After the events of Deir Yassin, there was much propaganda about it on both sides. When the Arabs inflated the number of casualties and perpetuated stories of rape and other atrocities, the Haganah did not stop these rumors; the Haganah was invested in showing that the Irgun and Lechi, smaller paramilitaries who had led the attack, were not up to snuff. Did the Haganah act properly in allowing the rumors of Deir Yassin to spread? Were the Haganah leaders short-sighted or necessarily protecting their image?
Should what happened at Deir Yassin in 1948 be called a massacre? After watching our video and this video of famous historian, Benny Morris, debate what the events at Deir Yassin should be called?
The events of Deir Yassin are regarded by the Palestinians as the beginning of the Nakba, and by Israelis as a watershed moment in the War of Independence.
- A first-hand Palestinian account reads: “[the troops] blew the door down, entered and started searching the place; they got to the storeroom, and took us out one by one. They shot the son-in-law, and when one of his daughters screamed, they shot her too. … We all started screaming and crying, but were told that if we did not stop, they would shoot us all. They then lined us up, shot at us, and left.”
- Irgun leader and later prime minister Menachem Begin wrote: “Not what happened at Deir Yassin, but what was invented about Deir Yassin, helped to carve the way to our decisive victories on the battlefield … The legend was worth half a dozen battalions to the forces of Israel.”Are these accounts compatible? How can two people view the same event so completely differently?

Should what happened at Deir Yassin in 1948 be called a massacre? After watching our video and this video of famous historian, Benny Morris, debate what the events at Deir Yassin should be called?
Is it possible for two people to have very different accounts of what happened? The Yanny or Laurel dispute helps us understand that it is perhaps quite possible to experience the very same thing differently. Listen to the audio and discuss how the Yanny or Laurel dispute can help us understand why many Palestinians and Israelis see the history of Deir Yassin differently (or maybe you think it does not at all)?
Engage your students in an experiential learning activity around the theme of Narrative, a theme found in the accompanying video.
Give your students our Kahoot on Deir Yassin!

How would you distinguish between history and narrative? Should they be understood as one and the same? When is it important to focus on one’s history and when should we focus on narratives?
In the famous game between Princeton and Dartmouth, the fans of each team interpreted the genesis of the altercation differently. What does this teach us about human psychology? If something “objectively” happened or did not happen, to what extent does this matter? How can we apply this to the story of Deir Yassin?
Ultimately, what matters more: the actual events that took place or the impact that they had on both the Israeli and Palestinian psyche?
Yuval Noah Harari in his book, Sapiens writes: “Do we focus on the aristocracy, the simple peasants, or the pigs and the crocodiles. History isn’t a single narrative, but thousands of alternative narratives. Whenever we choose to tell one, we are also choosing to silence others” (p.100). Whose narratives should be sharing with this story? Are there times that not all narratives should be shared? When thinking about this quote, come up with a personal example in which you can think of this being true in your own life. Describe the situation, and how other people saw the same story in a different way.
Picture yourself in Palestine (before it was called Israel) in April 1948. If you are Jewish, what are you experiencing? If you are Palestinian, what are you experiencing?
War is ugly. Human history is fraught with wars in every corner of the world, and war rages in many parts of the world today. Most atrocities will never be known to most people, even today in the digital age. Israel prides itself on having a strong code of ethics and an extremely moral IDF. Is Israel held (or does it hold itself) to too high a standard? Is there a reason people remember this one event – is it an outlier in Israel’s history? Today, should Israel hold itself to this standard or be ok with conflict sometimes having ugly consequences?

Unpacking Israeli History Podcast, “Deir Yassin: The battle for truth”
Daniel Gordis, Israel: A Concise History of a Nation Reborn, chapter 7
Benny Morris, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VGkxvaxAy7s
Benny Morris, 1948: A History of the First Arab-Israeli War, chapter 4
Sami Adwan, Dan Bar-On, and Eyal Naveh, Side by Side: Parallel Histories of Israel-Palestine
Zipporah Porath, Letters from Jerusalem, 1947-1948
Menachem Begin, The Revolt: Story of the Irgun, p. 162-5
Ofer Aderet, “Testimonies From the Censored Deir Yassin Massacre” https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/MAGAZINE-testimonies-from-the-censored-massacre-at-deir-yassin-1.5494094
https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/israels-war-of-independence/
https://www.commentarymagazine.com/articles/were-the-palestinians-expelled/

Unlock these resources with a free account

Don’t have an account? Sign up now

Experiential learning activity is available for this video

Experiential Learning is a proactive way to educate with a focus on reflection and can take place in any academic setting: day school, supplementary school, camp, youth group, synagogue, college campus or university.

TOPICS

RESOURCE TYPE

MORE

Deir Yassin

Unlock these resources with a free account

Experiential learning activity is available for this video

The Latest

Who Is Isaac Herzog, Israel’s 11th President?

This Tisha B’Av, Jews Are Wondering, What’s Next?

What Does Poland’s Holocaust Restitution Bill Mean for the Jewish World?

Why a Druze is the Jewish Agency’s Next Emissary

Browse

Company

Connect

Don't miss out

Access these resources with a free account!

Unlock the interactive quiz with a free account

By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies. We use cookies to provide you with a great experience and to help our website run effectively.